 |
| Russia fines users for extremist search activity |
Today President Vladimir Putin signed a law that fines people who search online for content deemed “extremist.” From September 1, users may face up to 5,000 rubles (about $64) if they deliberately seek banned sites or materials .
The bill passed the lower house, the State Duma, on July 22 with a 306–67 vote. It cleared the upper house days later and went straight to Putin’s desk . Lawmakers said it targets people who make repeated searches for extremist content.
“Extremist” covers more than violent groups. It includes material on opposition figures, LGBT activists, blogs, books, and music labeled on Russia’s federal list of extremist materials . That list holds over 5,000 entries, from songs and artwork to news sites critical of the government.
The government says the law helps curb real threats. Officials claim it stops people from joining violent or radical groups online. They insist it shields ordinary users, not casual searchers, but they have not detailed how they will spot deliberate offenders .
Critics warn the law will chill free speech. They say vague rules may punish people who click innocent links or do research. Some analysts note that police already monitor searches and can use new rules to expand control .
Alongside fines for searching, the law bans promoting or advertising VPNs. Russians rely on VPNs to access blocked sites. The new rules punish anyone who markets or shares VPN tools with fines up to 100,000 rubles ($1,280) for individuals and 1 million rubles ($12,800) for firms .
Roskomnadzor, the telecom watchdog, said it will update its blacklist. Internet providers must block banned URLs and prevent users from finding them through search engines. ISPs face penalties if they fail to comply .
This law builds on years of tightening. Since 2022, Russia has blocked independent media, branded critics as “foreign agents,” and punished “fake news” on war coverage. This move extends state power deeper into private browsing .
Human rights groups say Russia now outpaces other autocracies in online censorship. They warn the new rules may target academic or journalistic research. Legal scholars question how courts will judge intent behind a search .
Many Russians rely on foreign messaging apps like WhatsApp. Experts fear the search fines law could sever app access if platforms fail to filter extremist content. Earlier bills threatened to ban or throttle services that don’t comply .
In June, Roskomnadzor blocked Ookla’s Speedtest service, citing security risks. Observers saw this as a test of the state’s power to choke foreign sites without clear legal basis .
Economists warn the law may hurt Russia’s tech sector. Tech firms rely on open research and global tools. Startups may lose access to libraries or code repositories deemed extremist. Investors could view Russia as a riskier market .
The law also raises questions about privacy. If search logs become evidence, users may feel spied on. VPNs offered a layer of protection. Now, sharing or selling that protection may be criminalized .
Offline reactions vary. Some pro-Kremlin voices hail the law as needed to fight radicalism. Others in the ruling party worry it could bog down Roskomnadzor with petty cases and distract from real threats .
International bodies condemned the law. The U.N. rapporteur on freedom of expression said fines for online searches violate rights to information and privacy. The European Union warned of deeper isolation for Russia’s internet .
Analysts note the law fits a global trend. Other countries, from India to Turkey, have tightened rules on online content. But few fine citizens for merely searching. Russia’s new model makes users liable before they even view extremist pages .
Legal experts say the key test will be enforcement. Will authorities pursue only repeat offenders? Or will ordinary users face fines for accidental clicks? The lack of clear guidelines may spur mass appeals or court challenges .
Some courts already struggle with backlogs. This law may flood them with small cases, forcing delays in serious trials. Lawyers warn it could undermine trust in Russia’s justice system .
Public opinion is hard to gauge. Polls show many Russians back censorship to curb violence and hate. But they also fear overreach and loss of privacy. Social media debates show mixed support and worry .
Internet users often share workarounds like proxies or browser add-ons. But with VPN ads banned, tech blogs may have to drop how-to guides. That may cut off knowledge-sharing hubs that once kept netizens informed .
Digital rights groups call for clearer rules. They want to define “deliberate search” and exempt researchers, journalists, and educators. They urge a process where users can contest fines before paying .
Russia’s neighbors watch closely. Belarus and Kazakhstan have similar bans on “extremist” content. They may copy the Russian model or tweak it for local use. This law could shape a wider regional web crackdown .
Some tech firms are already planning workarounds. Offshore servers, mirror sites, and encrypted DNS may see a surge. But if VPN promotion is outlawed, these solutions may shift underground .
Education may suffer. History and civic websites that discuss protest movements or extremist groups could be off-limits. Students may lose access to key resources on modern history and politics .
Meanwhile, activists note the law could drive more people to encrypted messaging and dark web forums. That may hamper state surveillance but fuel covert networks of opposition .
Digital entrepreneurs warn that Russia’s internet risks becoming a “splinternet.” A closed, state-run network that blocks global services will hurt innovation and economic ties .
Some see a silver lining. State-approved platforms may grow. Local VPNs or proxy services could pop up under tight licensing, giving the government a cut via fees and data access .
Longer term, experts say the law may face challenge at the Constitutional Court or ECHR if Russia still outlaws appeals. But Russia has withdrawn from the ECHR, making that path unlikely .
This law marks a new chapter in Russia’s digital control. It shows how the state blends anti-extremism goals with broader repression. For now, millions must weigh the risk of searching for ideas deemed dangerous by the Kremlin.
Watch in September for the first reported fines. That day will show how far Moscow will go to police thoughts online and how citizens will fight back.